Why Romantasy Deserves More Respect

And Why Readers Shouldn’t Have to Apologize for Loving It

Romance novels have long been dismissed as “guilty pleasures,” but a fast-rising subgenre—romantasy—is proving that these books deserve a lot more respect. A blend of romance and fantasy, romantasy is dominating bestseller lists, fueling book sales, and capturing the imaginations of readers worldwide. But despite its success, many fans still feel the need to defend their reading choices.

What Is Romantasy?

According to Netta Baker, an advanced instructor in Virginia Tech’s Department of English, romantasy is essentially Lord of the Rings with a central love story. “Instead of focusing on the journey of a fellowship, these books follow a romantic couple at the heart of the adventure,” she explains in an interview with WTOP.

Popular examples include Sarah J. Maas’s Throne of Glass series, Rebecca Yarros’s Fourth Wing, and Ruby Dixon’s Ice Planet Barbarians. These books don’t just offer thrilling fantasy worlds—they also feature complex female heroines, emotional depth, and immersive storytelling.

Why Is It Still Dismissed?

Despite its cultural impact and commercial success, romantasy—like romance in general—often struggles for literary recognition. Baker argues that much of this bias is rooted in the genre’s history: it was traditionally written by women, for women. And that alone, she suggests, is why so many readers feel pressured to downplay their enjoyment of these stories.

“If they acknowledge they read the books, they will always follow it up by saying online, in person, wherever, that they know they’re just for fun, that they know it’s not good literature, and that that’s OK,” says Baker. “But why is this the only genre where readers feel the need to apologize?”

Romance and Literature Have Always Gone Hand in Hand

Baker points to Jane Austen as an example. Austen’s novels, which explored the hopes, struggles, and societal expectations of women in her time, are now considered literary classics. Yet in her day, they were accessible and widely read—much like today’s romantasy books.

While some titles may be written for escapism, that doesn’t mean they lack literary value. Many romantasy authors craft intricate worlds, explore deep themes, and create characters as layered and compelling as those found in any “serious” novel.

Romantasy’s Impact on Book Sales

One thing is undeniable—romantasy is fueling a massive boom in publishing. As readers flock to books that blend epic fantasy with swoon-worthy romance, publishers are investing more in the genre, expanding its reach, and diversifying its narratives.

Baker believes it’s time to stop treating romance—and romantasy in particular—as a guilty pleasure. Instead, it should be celebrated for what it is: a powerful, imaginative genre that deserves recognition.

So, if you’re reading romantasy, there’s no need to justify it. Love what you love—and let the world catch up.