The Scottish Thistle
Cindy VallarHistorical romance
Available from Amber Quill Press
ISBN: 1-59279-629-X
November 2006
| Duncan Cameron traveled to the home of Rory MacGregor at the order of his foster father, to present Angus, of the Clan Gregor, Rory’s foster father, with a contract which stated that Rory would marry the man of Donald Cameron’s choosing and join the Clan of Cameron. In other words, Rory’s father had contracted with Donald Cameron for his daughter’s hand in marriage to pay back for securing them from danger. Duncan was the chief bodyguard to Donald Cameron, his foster son, and his choice to marry Rory. They were unaware, until Duncan appeared that Rory was secretly Thistle, a scoundrel who stole from those who had to give to those who had not.
The Scottish Thistle is a very detailed story of war between clans and a king who was dethroned. The love story between Rory and Duncan was beautifully told by Ms. Vallar; however, the book is more about history and war than about the love between two people. The story is interwoven between three years, and was somewtimes difficult to read. The history is comprehensive; I do not know whether it follows correct history, but surely those who enjoy the 1744-46 era would take pleasure in the in-depth study. The love story between the main characters was enhanced by the secondary characters involved in their lives. There were many clans and family members and at times it became a little confusing. However, this part of the story was beautiful—one of the best I have read. Their relationship, even though not always together, showed the true meaning of love in that each cared more about the other than themselves. The feelings that each had for the other was different from the norm. They were acutely aware of each other’s pain and felt problems even though they were far apart. I cannot express well enough how much I loved the “love story” part of this book. However, my only personal complaint was that the battles were graphic and excessive. I do realize that others might have another opinion, so I urge you to read it for yourself!
Overall rating:
Reviewer: Brenda Talley |
